Drilling Threaten Olive Ridley Turtles in Orissa
Bhubaneswar: When the endangered Olive Ridley turtles return to Orissa's
coast for their annual synchronised mating and nesting, they will
find large drilling rigs for gas disturbing their tranquillity.
The classic battle between environment and development is being played
out near the Gahirmatha Marine Sanctuary in Orissa's Kendrapada district,
174 km from here, the world's largest turtle nesting site. And also
the site for offshore drilling by India's leading business house,
One of nature's annual miracles could just be disrupted -- as 700,000-800,000
Olive Ridley turtles begin swimming their way to Gahirmatha with the
onset of every winter as if working to an internal clock to congregate,
mate and nest.
Conservationists from across the world have been petitioning the Indian
and Orissa governments to protect the world's biggest turtle population.
But it seems to have come to nought. When the idea of offshore drilling
for gas was mooted last year, wildlife lovers and environmentalists
the world over opposed it.
The federal ministry of environment and forest promptly set up a multi-disciplinary
expert (MDE) group in December 2003 comprising experts from various
fields to assess its likely impact of on sea turtles.
In the first report, the group denied permission to drill at the sites,
said a member of the MDE. The group had allowed drilling at another
site near the Gahirmatha for a limited period of six months when turtles
do not stay in the offshore waters, he said.
Nobody knows why this restriction was lifted and drilling was allowed
till October 2004, activists have pointed out.
In a revised report, the group also increased the drilling period
from six to eight months, ignoring published data by the Wildlife
Wing of the Orissa government that turtles arrive in the coast from
October to May.
"We fear this drilling period would clash with the presence of the
Olive Ridleys in the offshore waters and may adversely impact their
congregation and mating leading to likely nesting failure," said an
He recalled how the MDE had hastily revised several of its own recommendations
after a meeting in June in New Delhi on the basis of a presentation
by foreign marine biologist James Ray on behalf of Reliance Industries.
Ray's presentation was based on studies on the impact on sea turtles
of offshore oil and gas production platforms located in the Gulf of
Mexico and had little relevance to Olive Ridley turtles -- which occur
in extremely small numbers of less than 2,000 in the Gulf of Mexico.
Moreover, Ray had never visited Orissa to carry out a field study
on sea turtles of Orissa, the environmentalist said. Some members
of the group dissented from the final report.
Turtle scientist CS Kar said: "Since available scientific data is
deficient relating to sea turtles/marine life forms in offshore areas,
precautionary principles should be adopted till such information is
readily available in order to protect the country's wildlife heritage.
"This will only mean temporary postponement of the activities and
should not mean restricting the activities." The "precautionary principle"
laid down by the Supreme Court has been ignored by the MEG while allowing
the drilling activity. A conservationist from Orissa who is a member
of MDE disassociated himself from the final report by questioning
"Parallel proceedings about the likely impact of offshore industrial
development on Olive Ridleys is pending before the Supreme Court appointed
central empowered committee (CEC) and I cannot be a part of this illogical
drilling exercise," he said.
The CEC had directed the authorities to file a list of present and
planned offshore industrial activity in the coast of Orissa and the
likely impact on sea turtles, which is yet to be done, he said. Besides
Gahirmatha, the state has two other nesting sites Devi River in Puri
district and Rusikulya river in Ganjam district.
The MEG has also given permission for drilling near a site at Rusikulya
beach against the wishes of some members of the group, sources said.
Over the last decade, an estimated 100,000 turtles have died on the
Orissa coast, caught in the nets of trawlers and gill-netters and
for several other reasons.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This document contains copyrighted material whose use has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. India Resource Center is making this article available in our efforts to advance the understanding of corporate accountability, human rights, labor rights, social and environmental justice issues. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.