Coke Loses Fizz at US Varsity Over India Plant
New York: A US varsity has suspended sale of Coca Cola on it campus
after students launched a year-long campaign against the soft drinks
company's practices in India and Colombia.
Students at the University of Michigan are happy that their administration
has suspended the sale of Coca Cola products starting Jan 1.
The decision suspends 13 contracts with Coca Cola worth $1.4 million
annually because the company has not agreed to protocols for a third-party
review of labour practices in Colombia and has not developed protocols
for reviewing environmental concerns in India.
"It was a definite victory in that the university has realised that
Coca Cola is not acting on good faith and is not on deadline and not
really committed," Jory Hearst, an activist in the campaign at the
university, told IANS.
"We are concerned, however, with the language of the university that
it is 'temporarily suspended' but we kind of expected that.
"So it is going to be really important for the campaign to continue
and to continue pressure to make sure the actions that Coca Cola takes
are truly acknowledging the issues and not using public relations
as they have in the past four years. They deny as much as they can,"
But the soft drinks behemoth hopes it can salvage its concerns in
India and its contracts in the US. It is accused of depleting ground
water reserves at its plant in Plachimada in the south Indian state
On Dec 29, 2004, after a year-long campaign by the Students Organizing
for Labor and Economic Equality lodged a formal complaint about Coca
Cola's business practices in India and Colombia, the university sent
a letter to Coca Cola suspending sales on campus starting Jan 1.
The complaint alleged that Coke's bottling plants in these countries
violated various provisions of the Vendor Code of Conduct of the University
by fostering environmental practices in India that have depleted the
groundwater and led to products with unacceptably high levels of pesticides.
Nine other universities in the US have suspended Coca Cola sales according
to media reports. New York University, the largest private university
in the country, banned Coca Cola products from Dec 8 last year.
Others that have done the same are Rutgers University in New Jersey,
Santa Clara University in California, Salem State College in Massachusetts
and the University of Guelph in Ontario, Canada.
Coca Cola spokesperson Kari Bjorhus told IANS the company was pleased
that the University of Michigan has indicated its belief that the
company is "sincere in its desire to ensure fair labour practices
and a safe working environment in Colombia, and sustainable environmental
practices in India".
"The University of Michigan Dispute Review Board has made this decision
based on our inability to reach an agreement for another third-party
assessment before the deadline they had initially set.
"However, we are encouraged that the university has indicated its
willingness to continue to work with us to resolve concerns regarding
our operations in Colombia and India," Borhus emphasized.
On the accusation about depletion of ground water, Borjhus said that
monsoon rains in Kerala over the last couple of years have not been
normal, causing drought conditions generally.
"But the High Court of Kerala did a year-long study to determine if
our plant had in fact been contributing to the ground water depletion
in the area. This is conducted by various scientific experts. And
they concluded that we had not contributed to the groundwater depletion,"
The plant, which has been closed since March of 2004, was allowed
to be reopened by the Kerala High Court but the local Panchayat has
not given a carte blanche. Meanwhile, Kerala's customers were being
provided the product from the several other plants in India.
"It's been kind of sad. I've been down to the plant myself. It's a
beautiful plant. And inside the plant they have charts that they have
been tracking showing how they have been reducing their use of groundwater
steadily over the time that the plant was in operation.
"So they had been working very hard to conserve water. In fact, one
of the things that they had installed in that plant was rain-water
harvesting technology. So that they were collecting the monsoon rains
and returning them to the aquifers," Borjhus argued.
Asked how the University of Michigan's complaints were going to be
met, Borjhus implied activists had latched on to Coca Cola to get
"It's a very difficult situation because it is always hard to disprove
an allegation and prove your innocence when allegations are made against
you. It's much easier to make allegations.
"I think that in many ways, having a global brand is a wonderful thing.
But the flipside is that it provides an opportunity for groups to
attach their issue to your brand because they know they can get attention
for it," Borjhus said but she admitted the problem of water shortage
was "real" around the world.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This document contains copyrighted material whose use has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. India Resource Center is making this article available in our efforts to advance the understanding of corporate accountability, human rights, labor rights, social and environmental justice issues. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.