Democrats Accuse Coca-Cola of Pressuring Schools
HARTFORD, Conn. --Two top state Democrats on Wednesday accused the
Coca-Cola Co. of pushing sugary sodas on Connecticut students as lawmakers
again consider banning soft drinks from public schools.
Senate President Donald E. Williams Jr., D-Brooklyn, and Attorney
General Richard Blumenthal on Wednesday released contracts between
Coke and two schools, which include financial incentives to fill vending
machines with soda rather than water or juice.
Bridgeport schools receive a 38 percent commission for each $1 bottle
of carbonated soda sold, but only 30 percent for bottled water, according
to a 16-page contract provided to reporters. In Southington, the schools
receive a 45 percent commission for soda sales and 36 percent for
selling bottle of Dasani water.
Williams and Blumenthal claim such agreements show a need to ban Coke
and other sodas from schools, especially as policy-makers try to combat
"It's a cynical marketing ploy," Williams said. "They want to brand
into the minds of our children the Coca-Cola name and brand."
But R. Bartley Halloran, an attorney for Coke, said the contracts
with Bridgeport and Southington are five years old. The Bridgeport
deal has expired and Southington schools have since banned soda in
their machines, he said. Democrats, however, claim soda is still sold
during after-school hours in Southington and that the Bridgeport contract
with Coca-Cola remains in effect.
A call was left seeking comment with Bridgeport's attorney.
Halloran said he was not aware of any schools in Connecticut currently
receiving better financial incentives to sell soda, but acknowledged
that soda sales give the company a larger profit margin.
According to Coca-Cola, 75 percent of beverages sold in the state
in 2004 were non-carbonated or diet drinks, including water, fruit
juices, teas and sport drinks. The company believes the amount climbed
to nearly 85 percent in 2006. Coke claims carbonated beverage machines
are not available to elementary schoolchildren, but the machines may
be available in teachers lounges.
Coke also said carbonated beverages are not available to middle school
students during the school day. They are available to high schoolers
30 minutes after the last lunch hour.
Williams and Blumenthal also accused Coca-Cola of threatening to rescind
scholarships and money for athletic and academic programs if the legislature
bans soda in schools. Halloran said the company is trying to protect
its existing contracts.
"We intend to insist on upon our contractual rights," Halloran said.
"Don't change the deal after it's been made."
Blumenthal said his office plans to investigate whether Coke's charitable
foundation, which gives grants to schools, is also pressuring the
schools to stock soda in vending machines.
Halloran said the school districts can re-negotiate what products
to stock in the machines after the current contracts expire.
Lawmakers have been battling for several years to ban soda in public
schools. There have also been attempts to ban unhealthy snacks. Last
year, Gov. M. Jodi Rell, a Republican, vetoed a bill that that would
have banned most soft drinks and junk food from Connecticut schools.
Rell said the effort to impose state standards on local school districts
for nutrition and physical education "undermines the control and responsibility
of parents with school-aged children."
This year, the governor has said she will back a new version of the
bill, which would allow schools to only sell 100 percent fruit juice,
milk, water and drinks without added sugar and sweeteners. It would
also provide extra money for the school lunch program to those schools
that offer healthy snacks identified by the state Education Department.
The Appropriations Committee defeated the bill on March 31. Another
bill remains alive that includes the same language, Democrats said.
Thirteen-year-old Josh Block, who was shadowing a state senator for
the day, watched reporters interview Coke's attorney. The Weston Middle
School student said soda machines at his school sell Snapple products
as well as flavored seltzer, water and milk.
"There are lots of kids that want soda," he said. "It doesn't matter
much to me." Block was surprised by the legislature's intense interest
in the issue.
"I think parents should discuss it with kids," he said. "I don't think
the state should make the decision."
FAIR USE NOTICE. This document contains copyrighted material whose use has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. India Resource Center is making this article available in our efforts to advance the understanding of corporate accountability, human rights, labor rights, social and environmental justice issues. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.