Radical Ruling Proposed on Food Advertising
The Committee for Advertising Practice is close to ratifying a plan
that would see the introduction of advertising restrictions on all
food and drink products in non-broadcast media - except for fruit
MediaGuardian.co.uk can reveal that the radical plan, raised in discussion
at the Department of Health's food and drink advertising and promotion
forum today, goes further than Ofcom's obesity reduction strategy
that applies to TV ads only.
Ofcom has banned the advertising of junk food to children, determined
by a nutrient-profiling model developed by the Food Standards Agency
to identify products high in fat salt and sugar.
The extension of advertising restrictions to non-broadcast media -
such as magazines, the internet, newspapers and billboards and cinema
- is handled by CAP, the advertising industry's self-regulatory body.
CAP had planned to meet tomorrow to discuss whether to adopt the positioning
- understood to be supported by the vast majority of its member groups
- but the meeting has been postponed until Ofcom reports back on its
final consultation on TV advertising.
CAP members almost universally disagree with the FSA's model of determining
what is "junk" food on the basis that it is too inaccurate.
Under the system products such as raisins, certain types of honey,
All-Bran, Marmite, cheese and Greek yoghurt would be banned, and on
the other chicken nuggets, curry and plain white bread escape.
The simplified system CAP is looking at introducing would provide
an exemption category - currently only fruit and vegetables - meaning
that the likes of milk, water, low-fat yoghurt and mineral or pro-biotic
drinks would be banned.
The proposed CAP system has not yet been agreed by all members.
The likes of the Newspaper Publishers Association states that it still
believes that any translation of extending any ad restrictions to
non-broadcast media is yet to be decided.
However, in July last year Andrew Brown, the then director general
of the Advertising Association, voluntarily offered, on behalf of
industry, to extend the proposed broadcast restrictions to non-broadcast
However, this was before Ofcom said it would look to extend restrictions
to under-16s - it had initially been focussed on under 12s only -
and that it would adopt the nutrient profiling model to identify "junk"
Mr Brown's offer related to the content of advertising.
Specifically, a ban on licensed characters - but not the likes of
manufacturer's own icons such as Tony the Tiger - and the use of celebrities
who overly appeal to young children.
Despite CAP's blanket ban proposal being more wide-ranging than the
FSA's profiling system, campaigning groups are likely to be angered.
The move, if ratified, will be seen to undermine the FSA's system
if it is not adopted across all media.
Ofcom is expected to come back within the next few days on its final
consultation on TV advertising.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This document contains copyrighted material whose use has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. India Resource Center is making this article available in our efforts to advance the understanding of corporate accountability, human rights, labor rights, social and environmental justice issues. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.